Well the one thing that stands out is that the first ingredient is not chicken - it is chicken-by-product. The third ingredient is chicken. Are chicken organs higher in protein and better than chicken itself?? I don't know. The one thing I do know is that there are so many of Marshall's babies out there without homes - I would never support their company by buying their food so they can produce more babies. Also - Marshall's is not known for their high-quality food, so I cannot imagine they would have high-quality by-product... Tammy L. Sinclair (Not a Marshall's fan!!) [Posted in FML 7971]