To All.. Thanks for the responses...at least our 4 furballs are not out there alone. In communicating with 8 in 1 it appears that their original supplier of the treats went out of business so they chose another supplier. Well, the newsflash for 8 in 1 is that they won't be selling this new stuff for long since it appears that many of our fuzzies have wonderfully discriminating tastes and won't eat this yucky formula anyway... Joe...and the 4 furballs (Marshmallow, Rickii, Tenster and Aramis (aka Mr. No Treat is Good Enough for Me) [Posted in FML issue 4628]