The previous posting had misinformed information or was misread. Below is the correct information regarding PATH VALLEY and PROFESSIONAL KITTEN CHICKEN & RICE PATH VALLEY, second ingredient is chicken meal (which is good) . Chicken meal would be acceptable for human food, it's just ground up chicken and the third ingredient is whole grain brown rice (also is good). PROFESSIONAL KITTEN CHICKEN & RICE, second ingredient is Chicken by Product Meal (chicken by-products are what's left over from human grade foods, feathers, feet, fur, guts, etc. and not nutritious at all (not good) and the third ingredient is rice flour which really is not that nutritious. Harriett H. H. [Posted in FML issue 3602]